 |
| Part IV: The Kaivalya Pada |
|
| Chapter
106: The Dual Pull of Purusha and Objects |
|
Listen to the audio of this discourse
Download the MP3 audio |
|
The
awareness of the mind in any given condition is constituted of two
phases - namely, the object side and the subject side. It is like a buffer
standing between the object on one side and the atman, or the purusha,
on the other side. Therefore, it has intimation from two different directions,
and it combines the messages received from the purusha and the objects
at one and the same time. This point is elucidated in one sutra of
Patanjali which says: draṣṭṛ dṛśya uparaktaṁ cittaṁ
sarvārtham (IV.23).
Drastr and drisya mean the subject and the object. Uparaktam
cittam: the mind is influenced by both these. It is standing in between the
true subject, which is the purusha, and the object. Thus, it has a character
of the object, and also a character of the subject, so that the combination of
these two factors makes it a very enigmatic something. We cannot say whether it
is something belonging to the world of objects, or something which is
transcendent - namely, spiritual in nature.
The
mind cannot be easily studied because it has the character of materiality as
well as spirituality both combined. The spiritual impact which it receives from
the purusha makes it appear intelligent and assume the character of the
subject itself, while the impact that it receives from the objects makes it
coloured in respect of the objects, and it takes the shape of the objects. Sarvartham
means objectively conscious in variegated manners. The mind has various objects
presented before it on account of its peculiar position between the absolute
object and the absolute subject. The absolute object is the material that is
presented before the mind. The absolute subject is the purusha, or the
transcendent consciousness. Hence, we are pulled from two different directions
as minds in our individual capacities. We have an urge from the purusha
side, and also an urge from the object side. So we can imagine our status in
this world.
We
are influenced by two contrary sides, or realms, at one and the same time. Thus
it is that we entertain desires for objects and get contaminated by the various
modifications of objects. There is a tremendous impress made upon the mind by
the transformations which the objects undergo in the world outside. But, at the
same time, there is also a higher aspiration present in us. We are mortals with
an immortal aspiration. This peculiar characteristic in us is due to this
juncture at which the mind is placed, by which it is mortal and immortal at the
same time - immortal because it has the vision of what is behind it, from
where it receives intimations of immortal contents transcending its present
existence. But on the other side it is mortal, caught up in the meshes of
objective experience and desiring the varieties of satisfaction which
constitute this world of phenomenality.
It
is a very peculiar situation in which the mind is placed. We are pulled from
the earth side as well as from side of the heavens, from the objective side and
from the subjective side, from the material side and from the spiritual side,
from the external side and from the internal side, and so on - in umpteen
different manifold ways.
This
mind is constituted of many vasanas,or impressions of past
experience, as we studied in one of the earlier sutras. The mind is not
a compact, single, indivisible substance. It is a picturesque complex in whose
bosom we can find infinite varieties of impressions which have been accumulated
there on account of the experiences it has passed through in the various lives,
or incarnations, since aeons. Tat asaṅkhyeya vāsanābhiḥ citram api
parāthaṁ saṁhatyakāritvāt (IV.24): It is picturesque and
variegated on account of containing an infinite number of impressions of past
experience, which become the causative factors of future experience of a
similar kind. Yet, with all this infinite content of vasanas, or
impressions, within itself, the mind is not absolutely independent. Parartham:
It is dependent. It is dependent because its very function is directed by the
energy of something which is different from itself. The energy for the function
of the mind comes from the purusha, the Supreme Transcendent
Being.
Samhatyakaritvat: The mind is an assemblage of vasanas.
An assemblage, or a group of varieties of contents, cannot be regarded as a
permanent, solid entity because anything that is made up of parts is subject to
disintegration and dismemberment. The inner constituents of the mind are
subject to modification of pattern, and this change in the pattern of the
variety of contents inside the mind is the cause of the change of personality,
or individuality - or in other words, we may say the cause of what we call
rebirth. A complete reconstitution of the inner contents of the mind requires a
corresponding vehicle, materially, for the purpose of expressing the urges of this
reconstituted mind; and this new vehicle that is manufactured, or brought into
being, by the requirements of this newly constituted pattern - that is the
new birth of the body.
Thus,
the mind that is made up of many vasanas, or impressions, that is variegated
in its nature and multifarious in the various levels of its constitution is not
independent by itself. Its functions are for another purpose
altogether - the purpose being transcendent to its own existence. What is
the purpose? The purpose of the mind is the purpose of the universe itself.
What is the purpose of the universe? Why is there evolution? Why is there
change? Why is there activity? Why is there effort? The answer to these
questions is also the answer to the other question: why is the mind functioning
at all in the direction of objects with the energy that it receives from the purusha?
The
purpose of the functions of the mind is the evolution of the individual for the
attainment of perfection, which is called kaivalya or moksha. It
does not act unnecessarily. It is not an aimless activity in which the mind is
engaged. Even the so-called erroneous meanderings of the mind in the desert of samsara
are with a purpose. The purpose is the search for that which it has
lost - namely, the noumenon, the supreme purusha, the
Absolute.
Every
activity of every individual in any manner whatsoever, under any condition, is
a movement towards the Absolute, whether it is consciously directed or
otherwise. When the meaning of these movements is not consciously clear and we
are helplessly, as it were, driven forward by forces of which we have no
consciousness, then it becomes a blind activity, a kind of determinism reigning
supreme over our heads. Many a time we are under the impression that we are
unaware, pushed forward by the forces of nature. That we are unaware of the
intentions of the movements of nature is a different matter altogether, but
unawareness does not rule out the meaning that is hidden in these movements.
The total movement of nature towards Self-realisation is inclusive of all the
activities of the mind also, because the mind is a part of the universal nature
in its rarefied form. Thus, the movement of the mind towards objects is a blind
activity it engages itself in for the purpose of the recognition of a
perfection which it has lost - not knowing, at the same time, that its
movements are not compatible with the conscious intentions of the integration
of being, which is its ultimate purpose.
Externally
and internally, the mind moves at different times according to the intensity of
the pressure it receives either from the purusha or from the objects. As
it was stated in the sutra, the mind is influenced by the objects on one
side and the purusha on the other side. If the pressure from the purusha
is more, we are religiously inclined, spiritually motivated and aspiring in
noble directions. But if the pressure from the objects is more intense, then we
are sensually inclined and we run after the enjoyments of the world of
objects.
Hence,
there is this double activity of the mind. Nevertheless, in all this that has
been said about the mind, the sutra makes out that the mind is material;
it is dependent - non-independent - an assemblage of groups of vasanas
which are likely to be transformed at any time, which are subject to
modification and are, therefore, not permanent. The mind is entirely intended
for the purpose of the evolution of the individual towards the realisation of
perfection in the purusha. Viśeṣadarśinaḥ ātmabhāva
bhāvanānivṛttiḥ (IV.25) is the sutra which follows. The consciousness of
individual self, and even the consciousness of effort of any kind, ceases when
there is an awareness of the purusha as distinct from prakriti.
This is a literal rendering of this sutra.
There
is a perpetual feeling in us about our own selves, which lies at the background
of even altruistic activities. Even our movements in the direction of social
work and humanitarian activity is rooted in a peculiar self-sense, and this is
what is called atmabhava bhavana. We are never rid of this consciousness
of ourselves at any time. Sometimes we are faintly aware of ourselves being
there as individuals. Sometimes we are intensely aware; but we are never
totally unaware. The identification of consciousness with this self-sense, or
individuality, is a part of our empirical existence, and it is second nature to
us. It is ‘we’ ourselves, and everything starts from this seed of
the affirmation of the self-sense.
We
have to exist first as something, as constituted of a certain character, a
meaning, or a significance. From this existence of ours as an individual
associated with certain attributes arises various other types of meaning. This
self-sense, which is the root of this activity in this world - whatever be
the nature of that activity - does not cease even in different
reincarnations. Even if we take many births, the self-sense will not cease,
because it is that self-sense which is the cause of the reincarnations, or
rebirths, and it is that which undergoes this process of transformation in the
form of reincarnation.
Thus,
there is no abolition of personality, at any time, throughout the processes or
series of births and deaths of the individual. But it ceases only at one
time - when time itself ceases to exist. In the timeless awareness of the purusha,
the self-sense ceases to exist. It expires in the experience of the purusha;
it overcomes itself in a larger recognition of a higher self, where this lower
self gets absorbed and consumed with no residuum whatsoever. As camphor burns
and exhausts itself with no residuum, this self-sense, or individuality, gets
consumed in the fire of the flame of the purusha-consciousness and it
does not exist any more. There is only one self, which is the Self of the purusha,
and not the many selves, or individuals.
When
the individual self-sense recognises the existence of this purusha, it
at once directs itself towards the purusha. Visesa darsi, a
peculiar term used in this sutra, means one who has the awareness of the
difference between the true subject and the object. The true subject is the purusha
who appears to be involved in world perception through the mind, which is the
cause of bondage; and when the knowledge arises in oneself as to the true
nature of the ultimate subject, which is infinite in nature and not empirical,
then all empiricality or objectivity gets resolved into its original cause.
Then this self-sense, or atmabhava bhavana - ‘I exist’
consciousness - ceases, and there is an utter annihilation of every
experience that follows from the existence of the self-sense, namely, bondage
of every kind. Then what happens?
When
the mind is directed in this way towards the annihilation of self in the
realisation of the purusha, there is an inclination towards moksha.
It is almost the same thing; the inclination towards purusha and the
inclination towards moksha mean the same thing, because purusha
is moksha and moksha is purusha. Therefore, the two sutras,
which go together, almost convey the same meaning. Viśeṣadarśinaḥ
ātmabhāva bhāvanānivṛttiḥ (IV.25) and tadā vivekanimnaṁ kaivalya prāgbhāraṁ
cittam (IV.26). These
two sutras have an almost identical meaning, making out that when the
mind is inclined towards the discrimination between purusha and prakriti,
when there is the rise of right understanding in respect of things, the mind
gravitates towards liberation.
Kaivalya
pragbharam cittam is
a very significant term which means the mind is laden heavy with the
consciousness of liberation. It is inclined towards liberation, while now it is
inclined towards objects of sense due to the gravitation or the force exerted
by objects towards the mind. When this gravitational pull ceases or is
diminished in its intensity, the mind is able to move in the other direction
and feel the pull of the purusha. Vivekanimnam - inclined
towards understanding. The understanding that is spoken of here is not the
understanding we have in this world. In a sense, we can all be said to be
endowed with a sort of understanding. Everyone has some understanding. But
here, we speak of a different type of understanding which is a superior
knowledge of the higher nature of the individual, which is different from the
understanding which is associated with the lower nature connected with objects.
The inclination of the citta, or the mind, towards right understanding
means the inwardisation of consciousness, an introversion of the spirit towards
its own self, and an awakening which follows, compelling the mind to incline
towards the purusha.
All
this is hard stuff for us to understand, because we cannot understand what it
means - how the mind can incline towards the purusha when it is now
inclined towards the objects. We are not aware, even now, that the mind is
gravitating towards objects, because we have become one with the objects. We
have become object-consciousness so forcefully that we cannot even be conscious
that there is something other than the object world. Hence we cannot grasp, at
the present moment, what it means when the mind traverses this realm of
object-consciousness and goes to a different realm of a different gravitation
altogether.
When
the purusha begins to pull the mind, there is a pull received from every
direction while, when the object pulls, we are pulled only from one direction.
There is a great difference in this gravitation. Every object does not pull us
at the same time. It is only one object that pulls us at one time. Sometimes
one or two objects may join together and pull us for a particular purpose. But
the pull of the purusha, or the gravitational force exerted by the purusha,
is universal in character. It will call us from every nook and corner. It is a
summons that is received from every quarter of the universe because the purusha
is everywhere, while the objects are not everywhere. The object cannot call us
from all directions because it is in one place only. Thus, we are inclined
sensorily in one direction when the object calls us, and there is an attachment
of the mind towards one object.
When
the purusha calls, there is an efflorescence of the mind - an
opening of the bud of the flower of the mind, as it were - wherein it
becomes aware of the call it receives from the whole universe. The call of the purusha
is the call of the universe. The universe is the face of the purusha. It
is the expression of the purusha in the sense that the purusha is
manifest through the things of the universe. We will feel a kind of sensation
in respect of anything and everything around us as if they are friendly, as if
they are one with us, as if we are living in a family that is spread out around
us, wherever we are placed in this world. This is a rare and novel experience
in a higher state of spiritual aspiration and experience, and it cannot be
understood in the beginning stages. We will be friendly and at home at any
place in the world, in any circumstance. Even in a dustbin we will find heaven,
if this call comes. But until this call comes, we cannot appreciate or
understand the meaning of the way in which the mind is gravitated towards the purusha.
Well,
this is a very high and lofty state of experience which the sutra refers
to, and it is a question of practice. When we actually enter into the practice
of yoga, we will pass through all these stages. We will pass through stages of
various kinds of pull exerted in many ways, by various things, so that at the
different levels through which we pass, different things will look real and
satisfying. But, it is only in the last stage, where we can perceive the dawn
of the consciousness of the purusha, that the meaning of this pull can
be properly grasped. Until that time, there will be movement from one side or
the other side, and there will be an experiment made by the mind in respect of
one object or two objects, or groups of objects. Actually, it is the purusha
that is searched for in the objects of sense. We do not want objects; we want
the purusha only. Even in this wretched condition, it is the purusha
that we are asking for, not anything else. But the blinkers of the mind, which
prevent its perception of the universal that is present in particulars, has
become the cause of an intensification or attachment in respect of groups of
objects.
Thus,
there are very great difficulties on the way towards getting over the pulls of
even one level. At each level there is a great force exerted upon us by the
laws of that particular realm, so that when we are on the earth, the earth
plane pulls us so forcefully, so powerfully, that we cannot have even the idea
that there is another realm existing. When we are liberated from the clutches
of this force of the earth-consciousness, we will find ourselves in another
realm, and there the laws of that level will have an impression upon us and
exert pressure upon us. There, again, we will have a new consciousness of a new
world of new experience, and that realm will be regarded as the only reality.
At every stage of experience, in every level or realm, that particular realm
only will be regarded as the whole reality so that neither the past will be
known, nor will we be aware of the future.
All
these stages have to be passed through, and many births may have to be taken to
become fit to receive the conscious call of the purusha. Manuṣyāṇāṁ
sahasreṣu kaścid yadati siddhaye, yatatām api siddhānāṁ
kaścin māṁ vetti tattvataḥ (B.G. VII.3). After thousands and thousands of births
in various species of beings, we come to the level of this consciousness of
there being something transcendent and spiritual. And even among those who are
so conscious, a few only will succeed, says this famous verse of the
Bhagavadgita.
|