|
Alfred North Whitehead occupies a place in the history
of Western philosophy which makes his importance comparable
only with that of the great masters - Plato, Kant and
Hegel, who gave to mankind monumental systems of thought.
Whitehead conceives the universe as an organism, a process,
to understand which our notions of things, entities,
substances, and of place and time have to be completely
overhauled and transformed. We are generally accustomed
to think that material bodies are located at particular
points of space and instants in time, and that no other
body can occupy those points of space at that time.
This idea of what Whitehead calls 'simple location',
which falsely tries to explain things without reference
to other regions of space and time, is bound up with
the common belief that causation is the production of
an effect by a cause which precedes it in time. Whitehead's
criticism is that a causal relation between two things
is incompatible with their simple location, for two
things which are separate from each other cannot bear
a causally binding relation between themselves. Causation
as it is ordinarily understood implies that a knowledge
of the cause should give us the knowledge of all its
effects. This is impossible if we persist in believing
that things and events are separated from one another.
If the simple location of events is a fact, even inference
would give us no knowledge of the inferred events, for
inference requires that the events from which we infer
others should have an 'inherent reference' to the
inferred events in order that they may give us knowledge
of these latter; but such a reference is absent between
events that are really different from each other. Memory
of the past, too, would not be possible if all events
are utterly cut off from one another in space and time.
Our experiences oblige us to give up the belief in the
simple location of things and events. There do not exist
disconnected bodies or events at different points of
space or moments in time.
If, then, events are not separated from one another,
how can we distinguish between a cause and its effect,
between the events from which we infer and those which
we infer? Whitehead's answer is: By admitting a process
that lies between all things, a process in which things
themselves become parts of the process, a continuous
flow of events, which takes us to the conception of
the universe as an organism, a system in which every
part influences every other part, every event is pervaded
and interpenetrated by every other event. It is impossible
to find anywhere in the universe isolated objects existing
by themselves statically in space and time.
The theory of organism provides a solution to the problem
of the relation between mind and matter. We are wont
to think that mind and matter are two distinct facts
of experience influencing each other in some way. But
how can any mutual interference be possible if they
are separated from each other? The problem can be solved
only if mind and matter interact by a relation of process.
Nature flows into the mind and flows out transformed
by it into the objects of perception. Here, neither
of the two is more real that the other. The perceiver
and the perceived form one continuous process. There
are no subjects and objects differentiated from one
another. The perceived universe is a view of itself
from the standpoint of its parts that are modified by
the activity of its whole being. There is a continuity
of process between mind and matter.
The relation of substance and its qualities, too, as
it is generally understood, presents great difficulties.
We cannot say how qualities inhere in a substance; we
do not know whether they are different or identical.
The usually accepted view is that substances are featureless
things possessing only primary qualities, to which the
secondary qualities are imparted by the knowing mind.
Then there remains nothing in Nature except motion,
which appears as light when it impinges on the retina
and as sound when it strikes the eardrum. The world,
says classical physics, consists of mere electrical
charges, having no colour, no sound, no beauty, no good,
no value, nothing that we call a world. The world is
in our minds. What is real is electrical force, mathematical
point-events, symbols and formulae. And what of aesthetic,
ethical and religious values? Science has no such things
as these. We also know how Locke's distinction of
the primary qualities from the secondary ones led to
the astonishing conclusions arrived at by Berkeley and
Hume. Whitehead points out that classical science discovers
a featureless universe because of the notion of simple
location of things. It committed the mistake of abstracting
things and events from their relation to others, and
substances from the qualities which characterise them.
The remedy is the acceptance of a universe of organic
relations, where all facts, meanings and values are
conserved without contradicting sense, reason and experience,
and in which all spatial otherness and temporal distinction
is overcome in a system of universal mutual reference
of things and events. Space, time and events are organically
related to each other; nothing can ever exist as isolated
from other existences.
Whitehead learns from Hegel that all things and events
are internally related and that to abstract them
from their environment or their context in the whole
would be to misrepresent them totally and to conceive
them as what they are not. Matter is a group of agitations
of force which extends its body to the entire universe
and constitutes its stuff. The configurations of this
force are called bodies or events and their existence
and nature determine everything. Things are without
limits or boundaries, they really exist everywhere,
at every time, in every way. We cannot pluck a leaf
from the tree and know what it is to the tree, or cut
a part of the human body and know how it works as its
organ. The bifurcation of an event from other events,
of substance from its attributes, of cause from its
effect, of mind from body, of things from the rest of
the universe is a death-blow given to all right knowledge.
Whitehead propounds a philosophy based on the scientific
theory of relativity. The result is the novel concept
of the organism.
Whitehead's universe as an organism is governed by
the law of internal relations. All things are
all other things in every condition, and the relations
themselves are not independent of the things. Now, we
have to give up the habit of using the words 'thing',
'entity', etc. while studying Whitehead, for he
has pointed out that our ideas of thinghood are bound
up with our notions of simple location involving what
he calls the 'fallacy of misplaced concreteness'.
What we call a thing is for him a set of agitations
of force, a group of activity or energy, a configuration
of process or motion, and he calls such a bit of process
an 'actual occasion'. We shall, however, for the
sake of convenience, apply this term to things in general
or objects of our experience. Sometimes, Whitehead calls
these actual occasions 'drops of experience'. These
names given to the material of the objects of common
perception are to bring out that they are not isolated
entities but currents of teleological process, continuous
with all things in the universe. No part of the process
can be abstracted from the others and studied correctly.
Every actual occasion involves every other, and to know
any one is to know the whole universe. Actual occasions
are spatio-temporal aspects of process, a nexus of which
we call an object. An object is nothing but a continuous
process of actual occasions as we experience them in
their externalised condition. There is no fixed object
anywhere. An event is a series of actual occasions revealed
in perception as demonstrated in a molecule for a few
moments. Objects are more complex formulations of such
events. The objectness of an object is in its capacity
to be experienced in perception.
Every actual occasion is sensitive to the existence
of others, and thus to the entire universe. All actual
occasions take account of each other, and in some way,
subtler than even sense-perception, 'perceive' each
other. There is a kind of pervasive 'feeling' of
every actual occasion for the others in the universe.
Whitehead uses the word 'feeling' in quite a different
sense from the one in which we are used to understand
it, and makes it more fundamental than the conscious
level of the mind in waking life. This feeling is a
natural sympathy which the actual occasions have for
the whole, a general connectedness and unity of the
universe which they reveal in themselves by the very
fact of their constitution. This rudimentary feeling
or experience is, to Whitehead, of the nature of unconscious
'prehension' or taking into relation of the other
actual occasions, a grasping of the characteristics
of every aspect of the universe. The prehensions may
be positive absorbings or negative rejections of aspects.
The actual occasions are thus related both in physical
and mental life; the two are not features of distinct
orders of being. The process is feeling and reality,
and the energy of physics is but what we feel within
ourselves as minds, a feeling in our own constitutions
as actual occasions for the indivisible process which
is the universe. Every actual occasion represents and
feels a situation of the entire process, and its very
existence is due to the contribution of the rest of
the actual occasions; it is produced by the whole universe
by way of integration of characters, which Whitehead
calls the process of 'concrescence'. An actual occasion
is called more precisely a 'prehensive occasion',
for it has no existence independent of its prehensions.
|